Charcoal is a handy, quick-lighting, hot-burning gasoline supply for grilling sizzling canine within the park or slow-smoking barbecue. However not all charcoal is created equally, neither is it a one-size-fits-all resolution. It is surprisingly diversified. There’s lump charcoal, binchotan, briquettes, and immediate gentle—so which do you select?
We dug into the variations so you will know which bag to seize, whether or not you are utilizing a kettle grill to char some hen breasts or smoking ribs in a barrel grill.
So, What Is Charcoal?
Critical Eats / Russell Kilgore
Charcoal is made by burning wooden in a low-oxygen setting inflicting water, sap, and different unstable substances to prepare dinner off, leaving giant chunks of carbon and a few hint minerals. The remaining wooden (a.ok.a. charcoal) is a hotter-burning gasoline than the unique piece for the reason that vitality required to burn off these unstable substances is now not wanted. From there, it will get extra nuanced relying on the kind of charcoal, which we’ll get into beneath.
What Is Lump Charcoal?
Critical Eats / Katrina Cossey
Lump charcoal is closest to the unique block of wooden, or so we are able to surmise. The perfect lump charcoal is made by burning hardwoods like oak and hickory in an hermetic setting. For the reason that finish product is remarkably pure, it leaves clear, white ash, and any charcoal that doesn’t absolutely burn is appropriate for reuse. When shopping for lump charcoal, shake the bag and hear for small bits rattling within the backside. Your finest guess is a bag with the least rattling, indicating bigger chunks and fewer fragments and dirt. Lump charcoal is a good selection for long-cooking functions and barbecue, however it could actually additionally attain excessive temperatures, making it glorious for searing meat and the like. We examined 13 baggage of lump charcoal, utilizing them in each high- and low-heat grilling assessments. Beneath are our high picks.
Our Favourite Lump Charcoal
Jealous Satan’s lump charcoal lights rapidly and burns for a very long time (90 minutes in our assessments), offering even warmth all through the cooking course of. The corporate claims it’s constituted of sustainable wooden, and it doesn’t pop and spark when lighting, though it does produce a little bit of smoke at first earlier than settling down.
Earlier than attending to the technical facets of this charcoal, I will level out the “Good” within the firm identify. This lump charcoal is constituted of acacia wooden from Namibia in an try to stop grassland encroachment that threatens the ecology there. Now for the small print.
The Good charcoal is extra evenly sized than the Jealous Satan, and sifting to cut back mud that creates smoke, sparks, and pops is a part of the corporate’s manufacturing course of. It lights in a chimney in about quarter-hour, and the big lump measurement minimizes charcoal loss throughout lighting.
What Is Binchotan Charcoal?
Critical Eats / Grace Kelly
Now that we perceive the high-level idea of lump charcoal, making binchotan will make extra sense. It’s one factor to burn wooden in a low-oxygen setting. It’s one other to burn it at temperatures topping 2,300°F. This course of yields exceptionally clean-burning, smokeless charcoal that produces infrared warmth within the neighborhood of 1,200°F with no seen flame. Binchotan is superb for high-heat searing functions. Whereas it’s costly, it’s supposed for a number of makes use of, which means you may put it out by smothering it and reserve it for an additional cooking session. It’s the popular charcoal for yakitori and Konro grills.
Our Favourite Binchotan Charcoal
This binchotan from Jealous Satan burns sizzling and clear, as per the model. The infrared warmth sears rapidly and cooks meals from the within out. As such, it rapidly cooks and evaporates water from meals and has nice potential to go away the meals dry. So, that is charcoal supposed for quick, sizzling cooking and isn’t suited to low-temperature functions.
The Bincho Grill Retailer charcoal is a bump in worth from Jealous Satan and sells sizes between 0.75 and a pair of.5 inches in diameter. It’s constituted of oak wooden and likewise claims to be an efficient water air purifier (though we haven’t examined that).
Thai-style grilling additionally makes use of charcoal logs. The model Thaan sells a proprietary model constituted of fruit orchard wooden trimmings. Mild a couple of sticks of Thaan and anticipate 4 to 6 hours of burn time, with an extremely clear hearth. Thaan additionally makes lump charcoal.
What Are Briquettes?
Critical Eats / Greg Baker
Briquettes are in all probability probably the most simply acknowledged type of charcoal and are most frequently utilized in charcoal grills. Step one of constructing briquettes is similar as lump charcoal, however then the charcoal is pulverized, combined with binders, and compressed into the basic pillow form. Search for manufacturers with excessive hardwood content material, as some manufacturers combine extra softwoods, like pine or typically fruit pits, into their briquettes.
This rationalization doesn’t imply briquettes are inferior to lump charcoal; they’re just different animals. Charcoal briquettes are the summertime-in-the-park basic for grilling burgers and hotdogs. Briquettes are additionally good fuel for smoking, as there are methods, such because the snake method, of constructing a set-it-and-forget-it self-feeding system that ensures a constant provide of charcoal whereas sustaining correct temperature.
Our Favourite Briquette Charcoal
Due to its greater hardwood content material, Royal Oak Premium burns hotter and longer than many opponents. It deviates from the basic pillow form, with grooves molded into the flatter surfaces, rising the airflow throughout the briquette. Higher airflow equals simpler lighting and warmer temperatures. However don’t let the point out of hotter temperatures pigeonhole this charcoal; it’s additionally nice for smoking and sluggish grilling.
Opposite to what many consider, probably the most generally used woods for barbecue isn’t hickory or mesquite—it’s oak. Oak presents a particular smoke taste however is extra refined than the opposite two, which may overwhelm and typically flip bitter when utilized in giant portions. B&B Competitors Oak Briquettes present that refined taste in lengthy cooks, however this charcoal additionally burns sizzling for searing burgers and steaks. It burns right down to gentle clear ash when accomplished, making cleanup straightforward.
What Are Immediate-Mild Briquettes?
Critical Eats / Russell Kilgore
It doesn’t matter when you’re a newbie or a seasoned griller; ultimately, you’ll use no less than one bag of instant-light charcoal. Immediate gentle is a charcoal born of comfort and is solely briquettes pre-coated in a lighter fluid-like substance. Add it to your charcoal chimney and maintain a match to some briquettes, and also you’re able to grill. A phrase of warning: Don’t be me. I as soon as tried to gentle an unopened bag of immediate gentle, pondering the bag’s paper would help in lighting. It did, however I didn’t issue within the physics of increasing warmth in an enclosed container, and, effectively, BOOM.
Our Favourite Immediate-Mild Charcoal
Kingsford is an easy-to-use instant-light charcoal obtainable in lots of grocery and specialty shops, so that you received’t should look exhausting for it. Due to the lighter fluid coating, be certain your charcoal fully burns right down to coals earlier than including meals to the grill to keep away from potential off flavors or toxins. Likewise, if it’s essential add extra charcoal throughout cooking, both add it with no meals on the grill and let it burn down or gentle it in a charcoal chimney and add it to your grill when it’s prepared.
FAQs
How do you gentle charcoal on a grill?
There are a couple of methods of lighting charcoal briquettes and lump charcoal. I’ll record them so as of effectiveness and comfort.
- Charcoal chimney starters: Chimneys are the best and only means. Place your charcoal within the hopper, add crumpled paper to the underside chamber, and light-weight the paper. By design, pure convection happens, lighting the charcoal above, which you then dump into your grill for cooking. A reusable chimney requires no particular equipment besides some paper and a lighter.
- Lighter blocks: I’ll use “block” as a descriptor, as lighter blocks might be product of dense, compressed sawdust, like these from Masterbuilt, or bundles of wooden fiber like these from Kingsford. In both case, the block consists of wooden coated with flammable materials, typically innocent paraffin. You place a number of of those blocks underneath your charcoal, contact a flame to them, they usually gentle the charcoal.
- Lighter fluid: Use it when you should. Sure, lighter fluid is efficient when utilized correctly, however there are some tips for minimizing off-flavors. Many individuals douse their charcoal in lighter fluid and instantly gentle it. That can work, however as a rule, it merely burns the lighter fluid with out igniting the charcoal. They then add extra fluid to a hearth that will or will not be visibly burning; the fluid flares they usually grow to be contenders for viral movies. Enable the lighter fluid to soak into the charcoal for 5 to 10 minutes, and the chances change in favor of lighting the charcoal and decreasing the possibilities of your immortalization by way of web presence. The identical guidelines apply right here as instant-light charcoal: Let the flames burn out fully earlier than including your meals.
- Propane torches: I’ve by no means had a lot success with these strategies, however I do know individuals who swear by lighting charcoal with a propane torch or an electric lighter. The thought is to use excessive warmth to the charcoal, and off you go. There’s one thing primally enjoyable about making use of intense flame to issues, like within the case of a torch, however the allure wears off when the charcoal begins sparking and popping onto your palms and arms. Not that I, uh, know something about that.
What’s one of the simplest ways to retailer charcoal?
Most charcoal is available in a bag with both an inside moisture-repellent liner or a coating on the paper. That protects the charcoal from rain, however after opening the bag, it does little to guard it from ambient humidity. In the event you reside in a very humid setting, you should purchase a moisture-resistant storage bin resembling one made for storing pet meals or a specialised charcoal bin. Both method, maintain your charcoal out of the rain or snow for finest outcomes.
Can you utilize charcoal for smoking?
Completely. My tastes run towards much less smokey smoked meals, and I discover that hardwood lump charcoal, usually oak except specified, gives a very good, refined, but distinctly current taste to the meals I smoke. Hardwood briquettes work equally effectively. What’s absent in charcoal is the water and sap present in plain wooden, so there’s much less popping, smoking, and creosote taste within the meals.
Are you able to reuse charcoal?
Sure. Whereas usually reserved for lump or binchotan, you may smother the fireplace by slicing off the air provide and saving unspent charcoal for an additional cooking session. (A moisture-resistant container is your finest guess for this.)
Why We’re the Specialists
Trending Merchandise

BAYOBID Stainless Steel Kitchen Utensil Set | 24 Pieces Cooking Utensils Set | Perfect Metal Kitchen Utensils set…

mafiti Oil Dispenser Bottle 180ml/6Oz Olive Oil Dispenser Sprayer for Cooking Air fryer BBQ Grilling Salad Baking…

URASISTO 19-Piece Home Tool Kit Hand Tool Set with Easy Carrying Pouch Perfect for DIY, Home Maintenance

Veluebay Kitchen Utensils Set, 12 Pcs Non-Stick wooden utensils for cooking, kitchen utensils set with holder, silicone…

Kitchen Gizmo Snap N Strain Pot Strainer and Pasta Strainer – Adjustable Silicone Clip On Strainer for Pots, Pans, and…

Garlic Press, Upgrade Garlic Mincer Stainless Steel Garlic Press Rocker, Professional Kitchen Gadget with Ergonomic…
