Many, a few years in the past, I used to be the sort of one who roasted and puréed my very own pumpkin for pie filling. I have no idea what I used to be pondering, and I don’t know what I used to be attempting to show, as a result of it wasn’t exponentially extra scrumptious than utilizing canned pumpkin—and it definitely wasn’t simpler. After a number of Thanksgivings that concerned peeling, roasting, and puréeing gourds for pumpkin pie, I lastly threw within the towel one yr and, like many different house cooks, selected to go the canned route. Not a single particular person seen the distinction, and it’s attainable my pies acquired much more compliments the yr I made the swap from do-it-yourself purée to canned pumpkin. Pumpkin pie has by no means been simpler, and I’ve by no means appeared again.
Severe Eats / Amanda Suarez
Many wonderful bakers I’ve labored with swear by canned pumpkin, because it’s a handy possibility that’s usually extra concentrated and comprises much less water than contemporary pumpkin purée. Until you’re taking the time to squeeze out or prepare dinner out the moisture from pumpkins for do-it-yourself purée, it’s most likely not price making your individual. So, to prepare for all the vacation baking forward of us, we determined to drag collectively 9 completely different canned pumpkin purées to pattern in our most up-to-date style take a look at.
I used every purée to arrange a easy pie filling by whisking it along with eggs, sugar, pumpkin pie spices, and evaporated milk, utilizing the very same components and ratios for every batch. (I really used the pumpkin pie recipe on a can of Libby’s as a result of it is a easy pie, and a recipe that presumably many house cooks use.) After mixing up the components, I then transferred every batch to a person baking dish and cooked them on the identical temperature for a similar period of time.
Along with utilizing the identical recipe for every pattern, I had our tasters strive every with out figuring out which manufacturers they had been attempting, as we do for all of our style exams. After tasting our means via 9 completely different pumpkin purées, we discovered one we’d be pleased to show into pumpkin pie—or muffins, cake, and even soup—plus two different worthy contenders. Learn on for our winners and make your life simpler and (tastier!) this vacation season.
What Is Canned Pumpkin, Anyway?
First issues first: Quite a lot of the canned pumpkin bought in america will not be really pumpkin. Based on the Food and Drug Administration, canned “pumpkin” is created from area pumpkin (Cucurbita pepo or true pumpkin) and/or different types of “firm-shelled, golden-fleshed, candy squash (Cucurbita maxima).” The group acknowledges that many firms combine pumpkin and different squash varieties to “acquire the consistency most acceptable to customers.” Libby’s for instance, makes use of a squash selection known as Dickinson. To maintain issues easy, we’re going to confer with all of the samples as pumpkin under, as they’re bought and marketed as such and style like what most People consider as “pumpkin.”
Severe Eats / Amanda Suarez
All the samples we examined had only one ingredient—pumpkin—and contained no extra spices, seasonings, or sweeteners. Canned pumpkin shouldn’t be confused with canned pumpkin pie filling, which is sweetened and seasoned. So, if you find yourself searching for canned pumpkin, be sure you learn the label rigorously.
The Standards
Nice canned pumpkin purée ought to have a heat reddish-orange hue much like that of an precise pumpkin—no neon shades, please!—and a subtly candy, earthy taste. It shouldn’t be bitter or salty, nor ought to it style just like the can it got here from. It ought to be moist and thick sufficient to scoop, not so skinny and watery that it simply slides off your spoon. And at last, it ought to be a comparatively delicate base for no matter you make with it, with out being insipid.
Total Winner
365 Natural Pumpkin Purée
Severe Eats / Amanda Suarez
Each single tester loved this purée. All of them thought it had a wonderful orange hue, with simply the correct quantity of sweetness and moisture. Our artwork director Sabrina favored that it was “not too dense and never too watery,” and our affiliate visuals director Amanda thought it tasted precisely like a pumpkin pie ought to. Although our affiliate editorial director Megan discovered this just a little chunky (“however not unhealthy”), she described its taste as “properly squashy,” which is strictly what you need your canned pumpkin to style like.
Runners Up: Our Favourite Canned Pumpkins
Farmer’s Market Natural Pumpkin Purée
Severe Eats / Amanda Suarez
This canned pumpkin had a yellowish shade, with a strong, earthy squash taste that our tasters liked. Although Sabrina thought it was barely dense and had a faintly bitter aftertaste, different tasters thought it had nice taste, with a easy, silky texture. Each Amanda and our senior social media editor Kelli commented that whereas it wasn’t overly candy, it had a pleasant squash-forward taste. As a facet word, our buying editor Rochelle, who’s an avid baker, was not at this style take a look at however famous afterwards that that is her favourite model.
Healthful Pantry Natural Pumpkin
Severe Eats / Amanda Suarez
This canned pumpkin—a Shoprite model—obtained rave evaluations from each single taster aside from Sabrina, who discovered it each dry and mushy, with a slight acidic aftertaste. Kelli, nonetheless, completely liked this pattern and wrote a glowing overview: “That is what you think about if you go to the pumpkin patch to pick your orange magnificence to bake right into a do-it-yourself pie to your Thanksgiving desk.” Each Amanda and Kelli described this pattern as having the moist and easy texture they appeared for in pumpkin pie.
The Contenders
- 365 by Entire Meals Market $1.79
- 365 Natural by Entire Meals Market $2.69
- Bowl and Basket $1.39
- Brad’s 100% Pure Natural Pumpkin $3.29
- Farmer’s Market Natural Pumpkin Purée $3.19
- Good & Collect 100% Pure Pumpkin $1.59
- Libby’s $1.97
- Dealer Joe’s Natural Pumpkin $2.49
- Healthful Pantry Natural Pumpkin $2.19
In Conclusion
There have been no true losers on this style take a look at, and a number of other tasters remarked that they loved each single pattern. That mentioned, it was a shock to us that Libby’s didn’t fare properly in our style take a look at, because the model is synonymous with canned pumpkin and a favourite amongst many bakers and residential cooks. Sadly, all however considered one of our tasters discovered Libby’s considerably watery and bland. Although we used Libby’s personal recipe to season and prepare dinner the entire purées, the model didn’t come out on high. That mentioned, not one of the manufacturers had been ranked poorly—however the ones with one of the best taste and texture had been our winners.
Apparently, our successful picks all occurred to be natural merchandise, and had a pleasing thickness with out being too dense or dry. Moreover, they’d a robust squash taste and pure sweetness that complemented the nice and cozy spices used to make the pie filling. Although all our tasters liked 365 Natural by Entire Meals Market, in addition they loved pumpkin purées from Farmer’s Market and Shoprite’s Healthful Pantry. We wager your pumpkin pie will likely be scrumptious no matter purée you employ, but when you will discover considered one of our three picks it’s going to be that significantly better—and if it isn’t good, no one will discover in the event you add sufficient whipped cream.
Our Testing Methodology
All style exams are carried out with manufacturers utterly hidden and with out dialogue. Tasters style samples in random order. For instance, taster A might style pattern one first, whereas taster B will style pattern six first. That is to stop palate fatigue from unfairly giving anyone pattern a bonus. Tasters are requested to fill our tasting sheets rating the samples for numerous standards. All knowledge is tabulated and outcomes are calculated with no editorial enter so as to give us probably the most neutral illustration of precise outcomes attainable.
Trending Merchandise

BAYOBID Stainless Steel Kitchen Utensil Set | 24 Pieces Cooking Utensils Set | Perfect Metal Kitchen Utensils set…

mafiti Oil Dispenser Bottle 180ml/6Oz Olive Oil Dispenser Sprayer for Cooking Air fryer BBQ Grilling Salad Baking…

URASISTO 19-Piece Home Tool Kit Hand Tool Set with Easy Carrying Pouch Perfect for DIY, Home Maintenance

Veluebay Kitchen Utensils Set, 12 Pcs Non-Stick wooden utensils for cooking, kitchen utensils set with holder, silicone…

Kitchen Gizmo Snap N Strain Pot Strainer and Pasta Strainer – Adjustable Silicone Clip On Strainer for Pots, Pans, and…

Garlic Press, Upgrade Garlic Mincer Stainless Steel Garlic Press Rocker, Professional Kitchen Gadget with Ergonomic…
