Wherever on this planet she is, Clarissa Wei not often takes the final piece of meals for herself.
Wei, a journalist, cookbook writer, and Critical Eats contributor from Los Angeles who presently lives in Taipei, grew up sharing plentiful meals together with her mother and father and youthful brother. “There was all the time a vegetable, a fish, a protein, a meat, fruit,” she says. “It could be method an excessive amount of for simply 4 folks.”
Her mother and father, Taiwanese immigrants who got here to america within the Eighties whereas Taiwan was within the midst of an financial increase—a.okay.a the Taiwan Miracle—“didn’t have any cash in any respect” rising up, says Wei. The plentiful meals of Wei’s childhood have been, she feels, a method of overcompensating for that still-fresh reminiscence of shortage.
“While you’re cooking a meal for folks in Taiwanese and Chinese language tradition, or among the many Chinese language diaspora, most individuals overcook—particularly at the moment when we have now a lot abundance,” says Wei. In these cultures, “a hospitable [host] is somebody who provides you extra meals than you may deal with.” The very best resolution to leftover meals, says Wei, is to not eat it your self, however to supply it to every particular person visitor. However on the similar time, consuming the final piece dangers offending the host, Wei explains—insinuating that you just’re nonetheless hungry and that the host hasn’t offered sufficient meals.
Getty Photos / James W. Porter
This oft-unspoken rule is about as common because it will get in terms of meals associated etiquette. In components of Spain, that final morsel is called la/el de la vergüenza; in Germany, it’s das Anstandsstück, or das Anstandsrest; schaambrokje within the Netherlands; trivselbit in Sweden; and so forth, with the phrase itself normally translating to some model of “the decency piece” or “the disgrace.” Simply as usually, nevertheless, there’s no identify for it in any respect—akin to in Minnesota, the place comically small bites of food will usually go uneaten for politeness’ sake.
So how precisely does one reconcile the truth that this rule exists in so many cultures—particularly ones so geographically and culturally distant from each other?
Krishnendu Ray, scholar and director of the New York College Meals Research PhD program, gives a few theories—one among which ties on to his personal life. Rising up in a middle-class household in India, Ray lived “in very shut proximity to people who find themselves hungry,” he says. In consequence, “one of many guidelines of etiquette was you by no means take the final morsel, since you don’t know who else is hungry,” he explains.
Ray, who has spent years residing overseas in international locations like Italy, theorizes that in cultures decimated by warfare, colonialism, or different main social upheaval, taking the final piece can really feel like a significant transgression. His shut European buddies—in addition to their mother and father or grandparents—“all the time have a proximate reminiscence of starvation,” says Ray, which he attributes to the enduring affect and generational trauma of two World Wars. In distinction, Ray says, his son—who has had a snug upbringing in New York, with “no identifiable sense of shortage”—will take the final piece with out hesitating.
“One of many guidelines of etiquette was you by no means take the final morsel, since you don’t know who else is hungry,”
In some circumstances, the rule of the final morsel might harken again even additional than World Battle I. In her ebook, Past Bratwurst: A Historical past of Meals in Germany, meals historian Ursula Heinzelmann writes, “Till the mid-twelfth century, serving huge quantities of meals and entertaining giant teams was a sign of elevated social rank. Thereafter, presumably as a result of the decrease courses might more and more afford sufficient to fulfill their starvation, overly hearty consuming was frowned upon by the aristocracy.”
Heinzelmann, who was born in West Berlin in 1963, was herself raised by no means to take das Anstandsstück. “With a good upbringing, you realize to not seize, greedily, for the final piece of cake, or no matter there’s on the desk,” she says. It’s one thing that “anybody with a ‘good’ household background and upbringing would have skilled, virtually like to not fart or belch.”
In Italy, Fabio Parasecoli, writer and professor of meals research at NYU’s Steinhardt College, realized an identical system of etiquette from his mother and father and grandparents. Parasecoli grew up within the Nineteen Sixties, throughout Italy’s “financial miracle”—a interval of speedy financial progress much like the one Wei’s mother and father witnessed in Taiwan. Throughout this era, Parasecoli writes in his ebook Al Dente: A Historical past of Meals in Italy, many Italians skilled monetary stability for the very first time. This included entry to inexpensive and plentiful meals—a lot of it accessible at supermarkets, an American innovation that was launched to Italy in 1957.
Even amidst this abundance, losing even a chunk of meals nonetheless felt unthinkable to folks like Parasecoli’s grandmother. “Why aren’t you consuming your whole meals?” Parasecoli recollects his grandmother—who lived by way of each World Wars—asking. “Are you leaving la creanza?”
Getty Photos / John Kuczala
La creanza—actually, “the great manners”—refers to that final piece on the plate. This was performed, Parasecoli says, “fare una bella figura,” or to depart a superb impression and present that you just’re not fearful about going hungry, he explains. The unstated rule of leaving the final piece stays even now, when starvation is way much less prevalent than it was throughout wartime, says Parasecoli. “It’s form of a leftover of a previous the place shortage was a actuality.” Nonetheless, he explains, “there’s all the time a rigidity—particularly for folks of older generations—between the need of showing well mannered, and the avoidance of waste.”
This final little piece is nearly by no means thrown away, nevertheless. In Ray’s case, notably when he would eat dinner along with his household in Delhi, he stated, “everybody form of prevented taking the final bit, a lot in order that principally, within the fridge you’ve got these little bowls of meals leftover.”
At Chinese language and Taiwanese dinner tables, Wei defined, the perfect transfer is to not eat the final piece your self, however to supply it to every particular person visitor. “Say there’s one piece of rooster left–you supply it to your buddy, you supply it to whomever is on the desk.” To do in any other case can be “extremely impolite,” says Wei.
Gender additionally performs a task on this unstated rule of desk etiquette. Creator and meals scholar Darra Goldstein says that an previous American perception taught ladies by no means to take the final piece, lest they wind up single—i.e., turn into an old maid. To Goldstein, this perception probably speaks to each the actual scrutiny positioned on a lady’s habits, and to “mother and father’ deeper fears about their kid’s future.”
In Italy, “ladies would go away extra meals for his or her children and for the person,” says Parasecoli. Whereas this habits hasn’t fully disappeared, he explains, the abundance of meals now accessible in Italy—a minimum of in comparison with pre-economic miracle days—has made it far much less prevalent.
“Say there’s one piece of rooster left–you supply it to your buddy, you supply it to whomever is on the desk.
Anita Mannur, Director of Asia, Pacific, and Diaspora Research at American College, grew up aware about an identical set of gender guidelines. Amongst her prolonged household in India, the place Mannur spent a portion of her childhood, “the ladies would all the time eat second, and the boys and the children would eat first,” she says. In Mannur’s personal home, nevertheless, these guidelines have been barely subverted. Mannur’s mom, who grew up in India, insisted that the final piece go to the youngest, regardless of the gender. “She was like, ‘I need you to consider different folks, have humility, however not since you’re a lady.’”
Within the Philippines, the place author and historian Adrian De Leon lived earlier than immigrating to Toronto at age six, anybody taking the final piece with out asking others might invite the Tagalog pejorative “walang hiya”—translating, roughly, to “you don’t have any disgrace.” In response to a TikTok video posted by the Philippines-based on-line publication, When in Manila, “Taking it implies that you’re thoughtless, you don’t share, and that you just don’t respect anybody else within the room.” Whereas the video comes off as barely hyperbolic, De Leon says it rings true. “I’ve by no means heard it known as that, however I do know precisely what he’s speaking about.”
Walang hiya additionally extends into almost all spheres of public Filipino, particularly Tagalog, life. De Leon was taught that no matter he did outdoors the house mirrored how his mother and father—notably his father—raised him. “Once I began going to remedy, it was really very shameful—it was walang hiya,” says De Leon. “‘Are you not ashamed that any person will know our secrets and techniques?’” he remembers his father asking him. An individual may also be known as walang hiya if they freely categorical queer or trans identification, or, as De Leon explains, in the event that they by some means act “further”—overly loud or expressive—in public.
As for the final morsel, it could possibly be one thing as coveted because the fish head—one among De Leon’s favorites—or as primary because the “sliver of rice” that his mom would usually go away on her plate. Selecting whether or not to take it’s a fixed battle—particularly as an grownup, De Leon explains. “I take a look at that piece of fish, and I’m like ‘I need to end that!’” he says. “[But] I’ll nonetheless discover myself not eager to do it [around family].”
Wei feels an identical ambivalence: “I’ve this inner battle generally the place it’s like my American aspect vs. my Taiwanese aspect, the place generally I’ll simply take the final piece, and be like ‘you realize what, I don’t care!’” she says. When eating with all Taiwanese folks, nevertheless, “I positively don’t take the final piece.”
Some folks, alternatively, by no means even encounter this rule. Amy Besa—co-owner of the longtime Brooklyn restaurant Purple Yam, which closed during the summer of 2024 attributable to Besa and her husband’s retirement—grew up within the Philippines previous to the nation’s interval of martial regulation, which ran from 1972 to 1981. Besa by no means had any hiya (disgrace) round meals whereas rising up. “That appears so detrimental!” says Besa.
In Besa’s case, it could have one thing to do with household dimension, she theorizes. Her older brothers moved out when she was younger, so it was normally simply her and her mother and father on the dinner desk, with no need for rationing; meals was primarily a supply of pleasure. “For me, consuming is such a cheerful method of communing with folks, proper?” she says. “So if any person needs to eat so much, then hey, nice!”
Getty Photos / Say-Cheese
In so some ways, that final chunk of meals symbolizes the wealthy, complicated, usually paradoxical dynamics at play once we eat with others. Meals, Parasecoli explains, “is the place you negotiate your identification, your social relations, your standing, your recollections.” The dinner desk is a spot the place Mannur’s mom can select to subvert inscribed gender guidelines and provides the final piece of meals to her youngest daughter; it’s the place Wei can determine to offer the final piece of fruit to her son “out of affection,” reasonably than a way of internalized disgrace, she says.
Regardless of these fixed negotiations, consuming dinner with a bunch doesn’t must really feel fraught. Every time De Leon’s household goes to dinner with their shut household buddies, “We all know that Tita makes hella meals,” he says, utilizing the Tagalog phrase for aunt or auntie. “And we’re going to freaking get pleasure from it it doesn’t matter what. And we’re going to take some house if we don’t end it.”
Trending Merchandise

BAYOBID Stainless Steel Kitchen Utensil Set | 24 Pieces Cooking Utensils Set | Perfect Metal Kitchen Utensils set…

mafiti Oil Dispenser Bottle 180ml/6Oz Olive Oil Dispenser Sprayer for Cooking Air fryer BBQ Grilling Salad Baking…

URASISTO 19-Piece Home Tool Kit Hand Tool Set with Easy Carrying Pouch Perfect for DIY, Home Maintenance

Veluebay Kitchen Utensils Set, 12 Pcs Non-Stick wooden utensils for cooking, kitchen utensils set with holder, silicone…

Kitchen Gizmo Snap N Strain Pot Strainer and Pasta Strainer – Adjustable Silicone Clip On Strainer for Pots, Pans, and…

Garlic Press, Upgrade Garlic Mincer Stainless Steel Garlic Press Rocker, Professional Kitchen Gadget with Ergonomic…
